I have a Spanish grammar book that teaches this construction of the passive voice: ser + past participle + por... is this NOT correct? That same book does not mention using estar
ser for passive voice?
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
ser for passive voice?
Yes it is correct but this lesson forms the passive using the gerundio so we must use the verb estar. If you keep working through the lessons you will encounter other ways of forming the passive which were not in your book.
Good morning Wendy ...
As Marsha says, "ser + past participle + por..." > "El gato fue observado por el perro" is fine, but "El gato estaba siendo observado por el perro" specifically portrays it as a continuous (progressive) process.
Regarding passives formed using "Estar + [just the] Past participle" [i.e., without the "siendo"], see my question and Inma's answer in:
> Verbs Tenses & Conjugation > Level B2 > Grammar > Library > Learn Spanish faster with Kwiziq Spanish >> Forming the Spanish passive voice with ser + participle (+ por) (passive - simple tenses)
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your Spanish level for FREE
Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard
Find your Spanish level