In Spanish «sino» is also correct to say 'except', right?

Shoji M.C1Kwiziq community member

In Spanish «sino» is also correct to say 'except', right?

Could someone please tell me why I was told it's wrong here in this quiz?

Kqiziq (B1): El año pasado visité todas las ciudades de Cataluña ___________ Tarragona (Last year I visited all the cities in Catalonia except for Tarragona). 

The options given: menos/sino/pero/aunque/incluso. 

I chose «sino», and I was marked wrong. The correct answer was «menos». I, of course, accept «menos», but why is «sino» wrong here??

This question relates to:Spanish lesson "except"
Asked 3 months ago
InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

Hola Shoji

Here "sino" wouldn't be an option for "except". Perhaps you're getting confused with when we use "sino" meaning "but" but not to express an "exception". Have a look at this lesson for "pero/sino".

I hope it clarifies it.

Saludos cordiales

Shoji M.C1Kwiziq community member

Thanks Inma.  However, I have seen this example in my Spanish dictionary: «Nadie lo sabe sino el director» (Nobody knows that except the director).

Is this ‘sino’ in this example also wrong and it has to be ‘menos’ ?? 

InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hola Shoji

Yes, you're right. Apologies. I hadn't thought about that option. 

In that other sentence: 

Nadie lo sabe sino el director.

this "sino" means "except for" (="apart from")

I'm not sure what the pattern is for this "sino" to be used as "except". Here's what RAE says about this specific use (see 2.3) - it just says it is used like that sometimes. 

Bear in mind though that in the very first sentence from the quiz, "sino" is not an option, as said before. 

Saludos

In Spanish «sino» is also correct to say 'except', right?

Could someone please tell me why I was told it's wrong here in this quiz?

Kqiziq (B1): El año pasado visité todas las ciudades de Cataluña ___________ Tarragona (Last year I visited all the cities in Catalonia except for Tarragona). 

The options given: menos/sino/pero/aunque/incluso. 

I chose «sino», and I was marked wrong. The correct answer was «menos». I, of course, accept «menos», but why is «sino» wrong here??

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...