creció vs crecía

AA W.C1Kwiziq community member

creció vs crecía

Hello, can you please explain the choice of el pretérito (creció) as opposed to el imperfecto (crecía) in this context?  I thought that perhaps the time marker "con el tiempo" might indicate a more extended time period, and thus signal el imperfecto.  Thank you!

Asked 1 year ago
InmaKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hola AA

I think it's necessary to look at the text around that sentence to see more clearly the use of the preterite as opposed to the imperfect.

If you go back to the text, you notice how in the first sentences the narrator is using mainly the imperfect because they're telling us some background information: the taxi driver was having a lonely life, he was having problems with alcohol... And then the dynamic changes and starts telling us about things that happened form a specific point: yesterday... and continues expressing things that are seen now as completed actions.

One of these actions is that their friendship grew. If you take that bit out of that context and see the phrase "it grew over time" you think of a progressive action using the imperfect, but within that context the narrator is seeing this as something that happened and he sees the end of it (not really the progress in time) - it is as if we said "y después de unos meses, su amistad creció"  (and after some time/some months their friendship grew- we see it as a result "past" that time, not "during" that time. 

To convey this "action completed" effect we use the preterite. 

I hope this showed some light (it's a tricky one though...)

Saludos cordiales

Inma

 

creció vs crecía

Hello, can you please explain the choice of el pretérito (creció) as opposed to el imperfecto (crecía) in this context?  I thought that perhaps the time marker "con el tiempo" might indicate a more extended time period, and thus signal el imperfecto.  Thank you!

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...